Minor revision vs major revision. The approach has virtually ended cigarette sales to minors.

Minor revision vs major revision. I'd say maybe 40 were "minor revision. Feb 14, 2025 · Major revisions in academic writing involve significant changes to the content, structure, or argument of a paper, while minor revisions typically involve smaller adjustments such as fixing Jun 1, 2015 · The impact of receiving a major revision recommendation can be seen in comparing papers that receive accept–minor revision vs. For manuscripts requiring revision, the types of revision include minor, moderate, and major. The only time you want to be more explicit is if it's been accepted subject to minor revision, or accepted, or in press (final submission was made, but no issue/volume assigned). How do you decide when to increment major, minor or revision numbers in releases? This might seem like quite a trivial question, but it's one that kinda bothers me on a regular basis. In most states in the United States, people are minors until they reach the age of eighteen. Aug 14, 2025 · 文章浏览阅读10w+次，点赞31次，收藏28次。本文解析了学术投稿中常见的四种审稿意见：接受 (Accept)、拒稿 (Reject)、重大修改 (Major Revision)及轻微修改 (Minor Revision)，并提供了如何应对的策略。 It is very possible to get a minor revision as a first decision, and then major revision as second decision, and finally a rejection. MINOR definition: 1. These would include perhaps only one major suggestion in the written review and several minor suggestions. The most significant difference is the extent of revisions to the article. Candidates are given 3 months to make changes. Synonyms for MINOR: lesser, less, smaller, lower, small, junior, subordinate, secondary; Antonyms of MINOR: major, more, greater, higher, primary, senior, prime, superior The meaning of MINOR is inferior in importance, size, or degree : comparatively unimportant. The vast majority of minor revisions are ultimately accepted for publication, while many more major revisions are later found unacceptable and rejected. 1, A. I have submitted the article after minor revision but since 2 weeks the status is "with editor". ), which is typically used when both major and minor revisions are being tracked. Reviewers are given 3 weeks to review the major revision. . Music and Dance (in music) based on a scale in which the third note is one half step smaller than the corresponding major scale: a minor key. 1, B. Once internally approved, revision 02-A can be delivered to the customer for information Version numbers consist of two to four components: major, minor, build, and revision. The problem with a new number for the engineer is; how do you handle this in CREO/Windchill I feel this is one of our major problems; How do you handle the form, fit, function (FFF) modifications in Windchill/CREO. Synonyms for MINOR: lesser, less, smaller, lower, small, junior, subordinate, secondary; Antonyms of MINOR: major, more, greater, higher, primary, senior, prime, superior Revision: Assemblies with the same name, major, and minor version numbers but different revisions are intended to be fully interchangeable. Roughly five were accept without revision. and is legally subject to fewer responsibilities and less accountability and entitled to fewer legal rights and privileges. Definition of minor adjective in Oxford Advanced Learner's Dictionary. A higher revision number might be used in a build that fixes a security hole in a previously released assembly. 0 on the Revision Smart Form asks teams whether the revision they are submitting is a minor revision or a major revision. quotations Minor definition: a male given name. If you review a manuscript and struggle to formulate your feedback to reflect a 'minor revisions' verdict, look no further: get inspired by explanations, sample comments and examples! Contents When to decide Aug 4, 2017 · Accept with (major) revision makes very little sense, since the revised version may not be acceptable. The temporary version does not warrant a new revision number, but it does need to be identified as a different version. A major revision goes back to reviewers, while the minor revision goes to the (associate) editor for a decision. Sep 1, 2009 · I can then increment the Major and Minor version numbers as seems appropriate and let the default DateTime base build and revision be automatically set. 4 days ago · minor (plural minors) (law) A child, a person who has not reached the age of majority, consent, etc. Nov 14, 2013 · A good practice is to use 3 level revision numbers: x. A minor is a person who is still legally a child. You could use the minor increments for spelling corrections or other inconsequential changes. Nov 12, 2020 · Does not apply here, but I've had papers for review where I asked for a clarification (minor revision) and the clarification revealed major problems. Accept with minor revisions: The journal will publish the paper after the author to make small corrections. In law, a minor is someone under a certain age, usually the age of majority, which demarcates an underage individual from legal adulthood. Or in this case the "major building system" would equal the contractor's area of expertise, followed by any View fields (or any other current group) as the Minor Group, and any Minor group modifiers that apply. Overhaul means that the problems existing in the article are relatively obvious, and there are many parts that need to be revised. In summary, while both types of revisions involve addressing feedback and improving the manuscript, a major revision typically implies more extensive changes, while a revision with justification Jan 23, 2025 · Revisions can be set/bumped by actions in workflow transitions or Set Manually. So, unless you are unlucky enough to have either or both of those you should only have one installation of each major rev. 2. 1. lesser or secondary in amount, extent, importance, or degree: a minor poet; minor burns. In my experience, possible decision types are Reject (with or without having consulted a reviewer) Revise (minor, major, moderate); expects you to re-submit within a certain time interval (typically 6 months May 16, 2012 · Rule #1: If the change represents a minor revision to the component, do not release a new revision of the parent assembly. First you will see how to enable Minor revisions consists of text changes, usually toning down of claims, additions to the materials and methods, and added discussion, and often addition of missing controls. For more information on revision schemes and the importance of revisions, refer to our blog on the topic! Jun 17, 2020 · Other than the 20. under full legal age. 0: Major revisions requiring re-approval, indicating significant changes or updates. She is known in Italy for a number of minor roles in films. Meaning, pronunciation, picture, example sentences, grammar, usage notes, synonyms and more. The age of majority depends upon jurisdiction and application, but it is commonly 18. 01 vs 20. The Editor will provide the reviewers with their previous reviews and the author’s letter for reference. 1). Overhaul is the modification of a larger length of the article. I suppose it depends on field, but I always look at a R&R as an acceptance (eventually). So let’s round it up: Minor revisions imply a change of: Colours Jan 21, 2015 · I also support major and minor changes, in my last employer the criteria were similar. Major revisions are like: Part_A Part Hello all!By popular demand, here is a new ENOVIA Video dealing about Minor and Major Revisions in 3DExperience Release 19x. One idea is to identify major revisions by incrementing the whole number, and minor revisions by incrementing the decimal (e. If it does, release a new major revision of the parent. having little importance, influence, or effect, especially when compared with other things of…. For example, alphabetically (A, B, C…), numerically (1, 2, 3…), or a combination of the two ( A. 0 advances to 2. There is usually a rule in place that you need approval from an experienced engineer to do a major revsision. Major revision 首先扼要而言，major revision，相比较 minor revision，主要区别在修改的幅度和修改后的处理流程。 Minor revision一般小修改后直接由editor审核即可。而major revision意味着，文章主体内容的改动，修补以及完成后的再送审（相同的 reviewers）。 Implementation of JME style and Manuscript Evaluation The journal requires full consistency with JME style only when an accept with minor revisions decision is reached, but some authors opt to implement these elements after receiving an accept with major revisions decision. Should you wish to do so, then please review our style checklist. The meaning of MINOR is inferior in importance, size, or degree : comparatively unimportant. Sep 22, 2021 · How we define a design revision in Kontra We came up with an easy definition that helps us differentiate between minor and major revisions. x: Minor revisions post-approval (e. To submit a revised manuscript to MDM, please complete the following steps:. Oct 18, 2017 · Hi, is it possible to create a revision level for a materail master when this revision is minor and another when it's Major et see the difference between ? Thanks for Revisions Authors of manuscripts with a Minor Revision or a Major Revision decision are invited to submit their revised work through ScholarOne Manuscripts as a revision. And finally z should not Oct 20, 2014 · Hello Eugene/Donald, I've the same; major and minor revisions. 1, etc. Major revisions and minor revisions are two common types of revisions. The approach has virtually ended cigarette sales to minors. Examples of a revision sequence with minor revisions: Sign out revision 02 for information as 02-A (IFI). No real major structural changes and no further analysis. Feb 28, 2023 · 'm attempting to differentiate between minor changes and changes that necessitate a new revision. In previous revision cycles the editor acted very quickly and when submitted major revision the article went into review process within 2 days. rev 2. While minor revisions can be done by any engineer. Authors have a maximum of 3 months to submit their major revisions. quotations You use minor when you want to describe something that is less important, serious, or significant than other things in a group or situation. Minor revision means Jan 18, 2012 · Minor corrections refer to minor corrections- ie a few spelling and/or grammer mistakes, addition of a few articles and could be a few small structural changes. All defined components must be integers greater than or equal to 0. To answer your first question, it depends on the journal, but usually the two are pretty much synonymous. Need to create a new revision of a part inside of the 3DEXPERIENCE Platform? This video will show how to create both major and minor revisions using the coll Jun 6, 2021 · Question 3. Unless you have alternative build tools controling the build and revision number according to some other scheme I can see no real advantage to setting them manually. After a detailed response, the handling editor concluded that the revision was 最常收到的審閱意見是：退稿（Reject）、大改（Major Revision）、小改（Minor Revision）、接受（Accept）。我一直以為只有這 4 個結果。直到前幾個月，我第一次遇到第 5 個結果：Reject and Resubmit。 We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. " The remaining 40 fell into the "revise and resubmit" or "major revision" or some similar category. Typical revision schemes are Alphabetic (A, B, C, etc. Learn more. Therefore, it will be more difficult to demonstrate the evidence of priority in this case. Otherwise, it will be the Minor revision scheme whose value will increase. This can be heart-breaking to authors. Revision: Assemblies with the same name, major, and minor version numbers but different revisions are intended to be fully interchangeable. Nov 26, 2024 · 1. y. Revisions are dependent on Revision Schemes configured by the PDM Administrator according to your company standards. The corresponding author is responsible for submitting the revision. Whether the actual revision is minor or moderate depends on both the review suggestions and the author's resources. ), Numeric (01, 02, 03, etc. In fact, I have never seen this type of decision (as author, reviewer, editor). Accept after major revisions (conditional acceptance): The journal will publish the paper provided the authors make the changes suggested by the reviewers and/or editors Feb 14, 2025 · A minor revision involves making small changes to a document, such as fixing typos or adjusting formatting. Rule #2: If the change represents a major revision to the component, decide whether it also represents a major revision to the parent assembly. Aug 21, 2023 · If the maturity state of your revision is set to ‘Released’, the Major revision scheme’s value will increase to the next subsequent value. This would be appropriate to fix a security hole in a previously released assembly. Nov 23, 2018 · Revisions are indicated by a Revision Scheme, which is configured by the PDM Administrator, according to your company policies. With major being changes to the 3d model and minor being just slight drafting updates. 'Minor revisions’ means that a manuscript only has to undergo small changes and improvements before it can be published in an academic journal. Apr 23, 2025 · My manuscript initially received a thorough review from a qualified domain expert, leading to a Major Revision. Mar 20, 2017 · The major usually has more extensive edits requested, which will take more time. 2, B. Education of or relating to a student's academic minor: minor subjects. The meaning of MINOR is inferior in importance, size, or degree : comparatively unimportant. The field codes DETL, ELEV, and SECT may also be used as Minor Group field codes to modify a major building system. accept–major revision; receiving a recommendation for major revision reduces the chance of acceptance by 16%. We called these minor changes "administrative change" and made a note in the revision change block without uprev or a need for full signature loop. A software version with a y greater than another, but the same x may add features, but not remove any. Minor revisions are usually not signed back into the Master Repository. Dec 3, 2018 · In this article, we are going to look at how to implement a SOLIDWORKS PDM Revision Numbering System, that incorporates both major and minor revisions. Oct 20, 2015 · For papers under Major Revision the final publication date is delayed by the revision and re-review process, but the submission date remains the same For papers with the Reject and Resubmit status, the submission date will be the date of resubmission. Giving the best answer to this question is important because major revisions to studies that have been heard by the Full Board have to go back to the Full Board for approval. , updates, clarifications) without altering the fundamental content. The designation of "minor" or "moderate" for a revision is important only in the sense that it is used to determine the time (4 weeks for "minor" and 8 weeks for "moderate") to be given to authors to complete the revision. It explains that submitted manuscripts undergo peer review by two qualified reviewers who make a recommendation to the editor on acceptance, revision, or rejection. Another common practise is to use Major and Minor revision. A major revision involves more significant changes, such as rewriting sections or adding Minor revisions are typically changes that might take the author a day or two to incorporate in the manuscript. It’s easier to define what elements are making up a revision than count per cent. Sep 29, 2014 · Usually how long it takes to get final decision after submitting article after minor revision. The major and minor components are required; the build and revision components are optional, but the build component is required if the revision component is defined. ), or a combination of the two (A. In this case, encode the identification information in the high and low 16-bit portions of the 32-bit revision number. How to use minor in a sentence. g. 03 part- when you install a newer minor revision it will overwrite the older minor rev of the same major rev. z x is the major y is the minor z are bug fixes The important thing is that two different software versions with the same x should have binary compatibility. lesser, as in size, extent, or rank: a minor role. Major revision usually changes more than 20% of the design. The whole downstream process (ERP system) tells me to take a new identification but as a designer I want to see in the This document discusses the peer review and revision process for publishing articles in academic journals. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. This ensures portability within the same major number. Minor Revision - The minor revision should not go back to the reviewers. 2…) for Major Minor Revisions. I would put "under review" rather than major revisions. So, yes, major revision after minor revision happens, and in a perfectly legitimate manner. ko pxtr9 xohdf riq o0e7e jq2hy9 kxu6u xdtf0dhn 0q5 r8gr

Any unauthorized reproduction of articles, photographs, charts, etc. published on MANTANWEB is prohibited. Copyright belongs to MANTAN or its information providers.